Interview: James Mwangi
How would you rate the competitiveness of the telecoms sector in Kenya?
JAMES MWANGI: The telecoms space in Kenya isn’t very competitive because it has a dominant player, Safaricom, occupying approximately 90% of the market share. The other operators end up playing an underdog role, which makes business challenging in many ways. Pricing in the sector is not based on competitiveness, service or products; instead it’s market control that is driving these things. As a result, Kenya remains a very pricey market for telecoms services and innovation has been stymied. With an environment such as this, it calls for innovative ways to open up the market and, in particular, niches of competency. This explains why Equitel has been so successful, because we have a competitive advantage in terms of financial services and can provide effective competition to a dominant player in these terms. As such, in just over a year, we were able to capture 22% of mobile money transfers as per the 2016 report from the Communications Authority of Kenya.
What impact has mobile money had on financial inclusion and economic growth?
MWANGI: We have been enabled by mobile money to achieve over 75% financial inclusion. When you have such huge access that almost compares to figures of high middle-income countries, it raises the question if inclusion is truly synonymous with impact. I think this can be equated to a country experiencing economic growth while you, personally, experience joblessness. I consider it to be inclusion without commensurate impact. Money transfer cannot be the sole measure of a country’s financial inclusion. Financial inclusion means an individual’s access to savings, loans, insurance and investments and actively using those products. It is only when a population effectively utilises those other channels that you can say inclusion has made an impact. All that mobile money is digitising is a delivery envelope; it’s not a financial product.
What factors contributed to the rapid uptake of mobile money in Kenya?
MWANGI: Mobile money, the service M-Pesa in particular, has had such significant success in Kenya because it is operating within the financial services space without being regulated like a financial actor. Other countries do not allow non-financial actors to play in the financial sector, and that is why no mobile money solution in other countries has been able to duplicate the success of M-Pesa. In other countries, mobile money is bank-led because banks are financial sector actors. That’s why mobile money has never boomed like it has in Kenya, because a telecoms company would not be allowed to operate within the financial sector without the appropriate license. There is a very simple reason why M-Pesa is limited to only money transfer and does not host savings accounts: they don’t have a license to provide financial products. Then the question is raised, should M-Pesa be regulated like a financial actor? It is a double-edged sword. First of all, you can’t regulate M-Pesa because it is being offered by a non-regulated entity and you can only regulate entities, not products. Second, if you use M-Pesa’s popularity as a measure of financial inclusion, you can’t go and then regulate a product that is driving financial inclusion.
How likely is it that other telecoms operators begin expanding into financial services?
MWANGI: I don’t think there is a very bright future for telecoms operators to offer financial services. This simply has to do with accessibility. Kenyan consumers were very attracted to services like M-Pesa because many didn’t have smart phones, so being able to send cash through SMS was a very attractive feature. Now, with the arrival of smart phones, customers will able to access their bank’s applications easily and choose that route. With connectivity expanding so rapidly in this age of internet of things, telecoms is already becoming considered a very rudimentary technology.
Read More from OBG
Improving the resilience of Africa’s agriculture sector
En Français Despite being home to 60% of the world’s arable land, Africa has yet to unlock its full agricultural potential. The 2023 edition of the “Agriculture in Africa Focus Report”, produced in partnership with OCP Group, highlights how the continent is deploying various initiatives to increase productivity in the sector, empower local farmers, and ensure access to inputs, technology and capital through farm-tech projects. Click here to download the report. …
In the game: The GCC is exploring e-sports as part of its diversification plans
As Gulf countries continue to pursue plans to diversify their economies and unlock job creation for their relatively young populations, they are increasingly investing in the growing industry around competitive video games known as e-sports. The MENA gaming market is expected to expand by some 19% by 2025 compared to 2019, according to a June 2022 analysis by strategic consultancy RedSeer, reaching a value of $5bn. The Dubai Multi Commodities Centre estimated in a June 2023 report that the marke…
Smaller footprint: A focus on sustainability is expected to reduce risks associated with climate change while bolstering bottom lines
As environmental, social and governance (ESG) concerns become increasingly important in the corporate world, insurance companies are emerging as potentially key players in the shift away from fossil fuel-powered projects. The launch of the UN-convened Net-Zero Insurance Alliance (NZIA) in July 2021 reflects an ongoing shift in the global insurance industry towards the wider recognition of the risks associated with climate change. Targeting Net-zero The NZIA brings together the world’s b…
“High-Level Discussions are Under Way to Identify How We Can Restructure Funding For Health Care Services”
Popular Sectors in Kenya
Popular Countries in ICT
Recent Reports in Kenya